Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Appetizer Platter
Turkey Club Sandwich
Italian Chicken Sandwich
Fish and Chip Sammy Sandwich
About
Over the Counter
Welcome to Over the Counter, a hidden gem in Worthington, Ohio that delights food lovers with its innovative take on New American cuisine. Nestled at 5596 N High St, this restaurant transforms traditional diner fare into extraordinary culinary experiences. With open doors for takeout and a warm ambiance for those who prefer to dine in, Over the Counter captures the essence of casual dining while exuding a quirky charm.
Upon entering, guests are greeted by an eclectic decor featuring relics and original flooring that tell a story of nostalgia. It's a setting that invites conversations and connections among friends and families alike. As you settle down, the attentive staff, known for their warmth and efficiency, are ready to guide you through a thoughtfully curated menu enriched with options for everyone, including vegan and vegetarian dishes.
What stood out to me during my visit were the rich flavors and quality of ingredients used in each dish. One comforting staple that guests can't stop raving about is the French Onion soup, celebrated for its deep, delicious broth. Accompanying it are fried pickle spears, a crowd favorite paired with a creamy homemade ranch dressing. Patrons like Elaine P. can't help but express excitement over the food; her palate was awakened by these delightful choices.
The menu also boasts elevated diner classics that aim to impress without breaking the bank. From the corned beef hash topped with an egg, to hearty breakfast quesadillas brimming with fresh ingredients, a variety of satisfying options await. As customer Mollie T. noted, it's diner food, but done right—with quality and flair that enhances the experience.
Not only is Over the Counter an ideal spot for brunch and lunch, but it's also a wonderful option for dinner. The atmosphere buzzes with a moderate noise level, making it a great choice for groups or family gatherings. With happy hour specials, a full bar, and an extensive selection of beers, there's always something to enjoy.
Moreover, the restaurant is wheelchair accessible and offers a range of amenities including outdoor seating, free Wi-Fi, and the ability to bring your furry friends along. It's a place where everyone feels at home, regardless of dietary preferences or needs.
As I conclude my visit, I share in the sentiments expressed by customers like Della J., who highlight not just the stellar food but the genuine customer service that can uplift a day. The overall vibe is nothing short of inviting, which is part of what makes Over the Counter a must-visit establishment in Worthington. If you haven’t yet discovered this culinary treasure, make your way there soon—you'll likely find yourself planning your next visit before you even leave!
Contact Over the Counter:
- Address: 5596 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085, United States
- Phone: (614) 846-1107
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Geez, I can't believe I never knew this restaurant was here! Met friends for lunch - loved it as soon as I walked in the door. It's a bit quirky with relic decor and has the original flooring (loved it). The waitress was very nice and attentive. The food! I only had French Onion soup (Delicious rich broth) and their fried pickle spears (really, really good with thin crusting and great homemade ranch dressing). One friend had chicken tenders which looked great - and he said they were very good pieces of chicken. I can't wait to go back! ”
“ Great service with amazing food. Typical diner food but elevated. Quality ingredients and beautiful interior. ”
“ I was served by Ella last weekend. She was so incredible and attentive! She recommended the breakfast quesadilla to me, and it was absolutely DELICIOUS! Phenomenal service and overall vibe. Her and I had such an encouraging conversation about life, she really turned my whole day around with her personality and kindness. Give this girl a raise! So cute inside, too. :) ”
“ What a great find! We were looking for Brunch and this place hit the spot! Great Corned Beef Hash with an egg over top. Casadea was big and filled with goodies. We will be going back for lunch and dinner soon. Menu looked varied and value priced. They were busy but staff was hustling and handled it well. ”
“ Consistently good food Good wait staff Friendly Super bar Lots of beer varieties too ”
“ I haven't been by OTC in a couple of years and decided to pop in to check it out. I went in around 815pm, knowing they were closed at 9. The staff was incredible with service and didn't make me feel rushed even though they were closing in less than an hour. I grabbed the Pretzel bites with beer cheese as an appetizer and the Route 23 salad with Salmon for my meal. These pretzel bites are ABSOLUTELY incredible!! I could stop in daily for these and never be disappointed!! They are so crisp on the outside and super soft in the center. It comes with 2 cups of beer cheese, which is enough, so you don't have to order extra ($0.99) The route 23 is full of flavor with goat cheese crumbles, candied nuts, and fresh strawberries!! The house made sweet balsamic dressing is the perfect pairing! I added the 8oz portion of Salmon ($7.99) vs the smaller 4oz ($4.99). The Salmon was cooked correctly and was a delicious choice! They had mutilple local and imported selections on Draft, a full bar to satisfy any drinks cravings, and wine. Thanks, OTC! Keep crushing it!! ”
“ We meet some friends here for dinner before going to a concert. It is located in a strip mall and has a little patio in front with some umbrellas. It does not have any heaters, so it would only be good in the warmer months. There was plenty of parking as the other businesses were closed by the time we arrived. On the inside it has some high tables with a bench on one side and high-top chairs on the other. The bar is located on the other side and has plenty of seats and televisions. Our server was nice and friendly. Big surprise, we started out with drinks. I got a whiskey sour with Makers Mark and a couple of cherries, to make it a wee bit sweeter. My man got a Yeungling draft, one of his regular beers. We shared the Beer Pretzel Bites, they were delicious. Oh, so crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, it even came with two ramekins of cheese. There was some cheese left over, which usually never happens. For my meal I got a cup of French Onion Soup and the Italian Chicken Sandwich. The croutons on the soup were large and crunchy, and there was a ton of melted cheese on top. I ordered the cup and it appeared to almost be bowl size. The chicken was grilled, with red peppers, lettuce, tomato, provolone cheese and some pesto aioli. The bread was something I had never seen before, grilled tomato swirl beard, like a marble rye. YUMMY! My man got the Counter Burger with American cheese, lettuce, tomato and red onion on a grilled bun, with a side of onion rings. It also came with a pickle spear on the side. Everything must have been good because he ate it all and did not even save me a bite, lol. We will definitely be back a couple of times. First for the brunch which is served on both Saturdays and Sundays. Second for the fish and chips and maybe a steak. ”
